Challenging lifelong learning policy discourse: Where is structure in agency in narrative-based research?
MetadataShow full item record
This item's downloads: 535 (view details)
Warren, S.; Webb, S. (2007) 'Challenging lifelong learning policy discourse: Where is structure in agency in narrative-based research?'. Studies In The Education Of Adults, 39 (1):5-21.
Can adult educational research on learning and identity counter the individualising of neoliberal government policy that seeks to constrain educational choices to those that contribute to government economic agendas? This article notes the recent move within post-compulsory education research towards an engagement with Bourdieu because of perceived limitations in the research and analysis of learner identities. In particular, Bourdieu is drawn upon as a conceptual resource in order adequately to account for the influence of social structure as well as agency. We contextualise our exploration of this conceptual move by outlining the way hegemonic policy discourses work to economise the field of UK education and training, specifically the cultivation of particular dispositions towards learning the responsible learner . We focus on a strand of work that has engaged with Bourdieu s conceptual framework in order to pro- vide a social-structural account of learner experiences. We do this through a brief exploration of the development of the concepts of learning career and learning culture . We ask to what extent the concepts of learning career and culture have worked, and argue that analysis of social structure deployed through these concepts, particularly the immanence of structure in the practices of adult learners, is less well developed. The article concludes with an outline of some new research questions to understand how adults engage with formal learning, specifically whether or not they are responsible learners and reflexive agents and what are the forms and meanings of these notions of responsibility and reflexivity. In setting out this research agenda we hope to contribute to furthering counter-hegemonic research on adults learning in a context of social and economic structural change, and to avoid being captured by the discourse .
This item is available under the Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Ireland. No item may be reproduced for commercial purposes. Please refer to the publisher's URL where this is made available, or to notes contained in the item itself. Other terms may apply.
The following license files are associated with this item: