ARAN - Access to Research at NUI Galway

Reconsidering the exclusion of metaphysics in human geography

ARAN - Access to Research at NUI Galway

Show simple item record Grimes, Seamus 2012-03-15T17:28:58Z 2012-03-15T17:28:58Z 1997-05
dc.identifier.citation Grimes, S. (1997) 'Reconsidering the exclusion of metaphysics in human geography'. Acta Philosophica, 6 (2):265-276. en_US
dc.identifier.issn 0355-1792
dc.description.abstract From its beginning as a systematic branch of knowledge, human geography was strongly influenced by developments in the other branches of the social sciences. Once a predominantly descriptive and ideographic discipline, human geography gradually took on a more positivist methodology. This in turn gave way to a series of approaches which included marxist, humanist and more recently postmodernist perspectives. As with similar paradigm shifts in other fields of knowledge, changes in geography were often attempts to deal with the deficiencies and criticisms of previous methodological and philosophical approaches. Because human geography emerged along with the social sciences, it was associated with the movement to distance scientific knowledge from metaphysical issues. From Descartes on a consensus emerged to exclude metaphysical questions as a necessary step towards the development of truly scientific disciplines. Within geography this view drew support from the influence of Kant and later on from the particularly hostile view of metaphysics held by the positivists of the Vienna Circle. Positivism was to take a firm grip on the development of human geography, moulding it to become "spatial science". Since the 1970s, a number of different approaches have provided a strong critique of positivist geography. Humanist geography in various forms attempted to counter the strongly deterministic perspectives on humanity presented by positivist and marxist influences. Some of these approaches have touched on the neglect of ontological issues, yet to date they have failed to examine the effect on the discipline of excluding a metaphysical perspective. The most recent development of postmodern geography, while it presents a strong critique of positivist geography, and argues for a greater tolerance of "difference", is nevertheless still quite hostile towards the possibility of incorporating a metaphysical perspective within human geography. This paper suggests the need to reconsider the exclusion of a metaphysical perspective in human geography, if the discipline is to make a more effective contribution towards helping policy makers deal with the many grave issues facing humanity. en_US
dc.format application/html en_US
dc.language.iso en en_US
dc.publisher Fabrizio Serra Editore en_US
dc.relation.ispartof Acta Philosophica en
dc.subject Human geography en_US
dc.subject Positivism en_US
dc.subject Metaphysics en_US
dc.subject Paradigm shift en_US
dc.subject Social sciences en_US
dc.title Reconsidering the exclusion of metaphysics in human geography en_US
dc.type Article en_US 2012-02-14T14:50:52Z
dc.local.publishedsource en_US
dc.description.peer-reviewed peer-reviewed
dc.contributor.funder |~|
dc.internal.rssid 1153289 Séamus Grimes, Dept. Of Geography & Cisc, & Cedres, Room 110, Arts/Science Building, Nui Galway. 2636 Email:
dc.local.copyrightchecked No
dc.local.version PUBLISHED

Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record